NFL · AFC South · Indianapolis, Indiana, US · Lucas Oil Stadium
From Unitas to Manning to Luck, the Colts have been defined by transcendent quarterback play — and by the painful gaps between those eras. Indianapolis is a franchise that knows greatness intimately and mediocrity just as well, searching once again for its next identity.
Updated March 21, 2026
Anthony Richardson played all 17 games for the first time in his career, throwing for 3,200 yards with 22 touchdowns and 14 interceptions. The tools are undeniable — his arm and athleticism remain rare — but the inconsistency led to an 8-9 record and hard questions about whether he can become a franchise quarterback.
The Colts' offense was maddeningly inconsistent in 2025, capable of putting up 35 points one week and 10 the next. Shane Steichen needs to find a way to stabilize the unit in his third year, and the front office is exploring whether a veteran backup or competition would help Richardson's development.
Jonathan Taylor rebounded with a strong 2025, rushing for 1,250 yards and proving he still has elite-level talent when healthy. The Colts' ability to lean on Taylor's rushing takes pressure off Richardson, and maintaining that balance will be crucial for Indianapolis in 2026.